MDR vs SIEM: What's the Difference for UK Businesses?

SIEM collects and analyses security logs. MDR provides continuous monitoring with human-led response. For most UK SMEs, MDR delivers better outcomes at lower total cost than SIEM.

Key Facts

£3,550average cost of the most disruptive breach for UK businesses
43%of UK businesses experienced a cyber breach in 2025 (DSIT)
99.9%of compromised accounts had not enabled MFA (Microsoft)
49%of UK businesses have a basic cyber security skills gap (DSIT)

MDR vs SIEM: Feature Comparison

Feature
MDR£8–£25/endpoint/moRecommended
SIEM£5,000–£50,000+/year
Threat detection
Log collection and correlationIncluded
24/7 human monitoring
Incident response
Requires security analysts to operateNoYes
Total cost for 100-person business£800–£2,500/mo£6,000–£12,000/mo (platform + staff)

When to Choose Each Option

Choose MDR if...

You need effective threat detection and response without hiring security analysts. MDR gives you the complete service — detection, investigation, and response — at a fraction of SIEM-plus-staff costs.

Choose SIEM if...

You have an existing security team, need to meet specific log retention requirements, or require deep correlation across diverse data sources. SIEM is a powerful tool — but only when operated by skilled analysts.

Cost-Benefit Analysis

SIEM platform costs plus the salary of one or more security analysts (£45,000–£65,000 each) typically exceeds £80,000–£120,000/year for a UK SME. MDR provides equivalent or better threat detection and response for £10,000–£30,000/year. For businesses without an existing security team, MDR is the clear winner on both effectiveness and cost.

Get a tailored MDR quote

The AMVIA Recommendation

The AMVIA Recommendation

For UK SMEs without a dedicated security operations team, MDR is the right choice over standalone SIEM. MDR delivers the monitoring and response outcomes that SIEM promises but requires significant in-house expertise to realise. Larger organisations with existing SOC teams can benefit from SIEM as a log aggregation and correlation layer — but start with MDR first.

Get a Free MDR Assessment

Frequently Asked Questions

Need Security Monitoring?

Our team can assess your needs and recommend the right approach.